How to appeal a Medicare denial in New Jersey
A denied claim, service or prescription is not the last word. Here are the deadlines, forms and five levels of appeal for Original Medicare, Advantage plans and Part D, and where New Jersey families get free help.

To appeal a Medicare denial, start with the notice that told you about it. If your parent has Original Medicare, that is the Medicare Summary Notice, and the first appeal generally must be filed within 120 days of receiving it. If they have a Medicare Advantage or Part D drug plan, the plan's denial letter starts the clock, and the appeal is due within 65 days of the date on that letter.
Every path has five levels, and each decision letter explains how to go to the next one. Most disputes are settled at the first or second level, often with a better letter from the doctor. This guide covers bills, services and drugs. For a hospital discharge or a rehab stay that is ending, there is a faster process, covered in our rehab guide and hospital discharge guide. This is general information, not legal advice.
Which appeal process applies to my parent?
It depends on whether the denial came from Original Medicare, a Medicare Advantage plan or a Part D drug plan. Look at the top of the notice.
| Coverage | First appeal | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Original Medicare | Redetermination | 120 days from the notice |
| Advantage plan | Plan reconsideration | 65 days from the denial |
| Part D drug plan | Plan redetermination | 65 days from the denial |
Missed a deadline? You can still ask. Federal rules let the reviewer accept a late appeal for "good cause," such as a serious illness, a death in the family, records lost in a fire, or wrong information from Medicare. Explain the reason in writing.
How do I appeal a denied claim in Original Medicare?
Ask the Medicare Administrative Contractor for a redetermination, using the form or the instructions on the Medicare Summary Notice. A decision generally comes within 60 days.
The Medicare Summary Notice (MSN) lists each service, what Medicare paid and what it denied. The deadline is printed on it. Under federal rules, you have 120 days from the day you receive it, and Medicare assumes you received it 5 days after the date on the notice.
You can file in two ways:
- Fill out the Redetermination Request Form (CMS-20027) and send it to the contractor address on the MSN.
- Or circle the denied items on a copy of the MSN, write why you disagree, add your parent's name, phone and Medicare Number, and mail it to the address on the last page.
Include anything that helps, such as a letter from the doctor explaining why the care was needed. If Medicare agrees, the payment shows up on the next MSN. If not, you get a Medicare Redetermination Notice.
Level 2: an independent reviewer
If the answer is still no, you have 180 days to ask a Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) for a reconsideration. Use the Medicare Reconsideration Request Form (CMS-20033) and send a copy of the redetermination notice. The QIC generally decides within 60 days.
Say your dad in Paramus gets an MSN showing that Medicare denied a scan. Call the doctor's billing office first. Sometimes a code was entered wrong and the office can fix and resubmit the claim. If the code was right, ask the doctor for a short letter saying why the scan was medically necessary, and file the redetermination with that letter attached.
How do I appeal a Medicare Advantage denial?
Ask the plan for a reconsideration within 65 days of the denial notice. If the plan says no again, it must send your case to an independent reviewer automatically.
Advantage plans call a coverage decision an "organization determination." Your parent, a representative or the doctor can ask for one before getting care. Under federal rules, a plan must answer a standard request for an item or service within 14 days, or within 7 days for items that need prior authorization (starting in 2026). A request for a Part B drug must be answered within 72 hours. If a plan misses its deadline, that counts as a denial you can appeal.
For the appeal itself, Medicare.gov gives the plan these deadlines:
- Care not yet received: 30 days
- Payment for care already received: 60 days
- Part B drug: 7 days
- Fast appeal, when waiting could seriously harm health: 72 hours
The plan can take up to 14 more days in some cases and must tell you in writing why. If the doctor asks for a reconsideration of care not yet received, the doctor must let your parent know. When the plan upholds its denial, the case goes on to an Independent Review Entity (IRE) without you having to file anything.
Many Advantage denials involve prior authorization for scans, surgery, rehab or home care. The doctor's office often handles those requests. Ask the office whether they have appealed, and ask for a copy of the denial letter so you can track the deadline yourself.
What if my parent's drug plan won't cover a prescription?
Ask the plan for a coverage determination or an exception. Standard requests must be answered within 72 hours, and fast requests within 24 hours.
Part D plans must give network pharmacies a notice explaining how to ask the plan for a coverage decision. If the pharmacist says a drug is not covered, ask for that notice and the reason. Then your parent or the prescriber can call the plan, write a letter or send the Model Coverage Determination Request form.
- Exceptions. To cover a drug that is off the formulary, or to lower its cost tier, the prescriber must send a statement with the medical reason. The 72-hour clock starts when the plan gets that statement.
- Repayment. If your parent already paid for the drug, the request must be in writing, and the plan has 14 days to decide.
- Appeal. If the plan says no, ask for a redetermination within 65 days. The plan must decide within 7 days, 14 for payment, or 72 hours for a fast appeal.
- Level 2. If the plan upholds the denial, you have 60 days to ask the Part D Independent Review Entity to look at it.
If your parent has PAAD, a drug that is off the Part D plan's list will not be filled by PAAD either. The state says the person must switch to a covered drug or the doctor must request an exception from the plan. Our PAAD guide and Part D guide for 2027 explain how the two fit together.
What happens if level 2 says no?
You can ask for a hearing before an administrative law judge, then a review by the Medicare Appeals Council, then federal court. Each step has a 60-day deadline, and the last two need a minimum dollar amount.
| Level | Who decides | Minimum amount |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | Administrative law judge (OMHA) | $200 in 2026 and 2027 |
| 4 | Medicare Appeals Council | No minimum |
| 5 | Federal district court | $1,960 in 2026, $2,000 in 2027 |
To ask for a hearing, follow the directions in the level 2 decision. You can use the form OMHA-100, write a letter, or file online with the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals. Hearings are usually held by phone or video. You can also ask for a decision based on the written record alone. Claims can sometimes be combined to reach the court minimum.
By level 3, the paperwork gets heavier. This is a good time to ask for free help from the groups listed below, or from a lawyer. Our guide to free legal help for seniors lists options in New Jersey.
How do I file a Medicare appeal for my mom or dad?
Your parent can name you as their representative on form CMS-1696, Appointment of Representative. Send a copy with each appeal.
Medicare.gov asks for a copy of the Appointment of Representative form, or another written document with the required details, whenever a representative files. A doctor can also ask for a fast appeal or a coverage decision on a patient's behalf. If your parent can no longer sign, a durable power of attorney or guardianship may give you the authority. Our guide to power of attorney in New Jersey explains how that works.
- Find the notice. Locate the MSN or the plan's denial letter. Note the date and the deadline.
- Call the provider. Ask whether the claim was coded correctly and whether the office will help with the appeal.
- Get a doctor's letter. One page on why the care or drug is medically necessary often does more than anything else.
- Use the right form. CMS-20027 for an Original Medicare redetermination, the plan's instructions for Advantage or Part D, and CMS-1696 if you are filing for your parent.
- Keep copies and proof. Copy everything you send. Mail with tracking, or note the date and name of anyone you speak with.
- Watch for the answer. If the decision does not come on time, call. A missed deadline by an Advantage or drug plan counts as a denial you can take to the next level.
New Jersey's State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) helps with claims and denials for free at 1-800-792-8820. For fast appeals when a hospital or rehab says Medicare will stop paying, call Commence Health, New Jersey's Medicare quality improvement organization, at 1-866-815-5440. Medicare itself is at 1-800-633-4227.
If an MSN shows a service your parent never got, that is not an appeal. It may be fraud. Our guide to Medicare scams in New Jersey explains how to report it to the Senior Medicare Patrol at 1-732-777-1940, ext. 1117. If home health visits were denied, our home health guide explains what Medicare covers.
Common questions
How long do I have to appeal a Medicare denial?
For Original Medicare, you generally have 120 days from receiving the Medicare Summary Notice. For a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan, you have 65 days from the date on the plan's denial notice. Later levels usually allow 60 days, except 180 days to request an Original Medicare reconsideration.
How do I appeal a Medicare denial for my mom?
Have her sign form CMS-1696, Appointment of Representative, naming you. Then file the appeal using the instructions on her Medicare Summary Notice or plan denial letter, and include a copy of the form. Her doctor can also request some appeals for her.
How fast does a Medicare Advantage plan have to decide an appeal?
Medicare.gov says 30 days for care you have not received, 60 days for payment, 7 days for a Part B drug, and 72 hours for a fast appeal. The plan can extend by up to 14 days in some cases and must tell you why in writing.
What if my dad's drug plan refuses to cover his prescription?
He or his prescriber can ask the plan for a coverage determination or an exception. The plan must decide within 72 hours, or 24 hours for an expedited request. An exception needs a statement from the prescriber with the medical reason.
Is there a minimum dollar amount to appeal?
Not for the first two levels. An administrative law judge hearing requires $200 in dispute in 2026 and 2027. Federal court review requires $1,960 in 2026 and $2,000 in 2027. Claims can sometimes be combined.
Who helps with Medicare appeals in New Jersey for free?
SHIP counselors help with claims and denials at 1-800-792-8820. For fast appeals when a hospital or rehab says coverage is ending, call Commence Health at 1-866-815-5440.
- Medicare.gov: Appeals in Original Medicare
- Medicare.gov: Appeals in Medicare health plans
- Medicare.gov: Appeals in a Medicare drug plan
- eCFR: 42 CFR 405.942, time frame for filing a redetermination
- eCFR: 42 CFR 422.568, timeframes for organization determinations
- eCFR: 42 CFR 423.562, Part D grievances and appeals, general provisions
- eCFR: 42 CFR 423.568, standard coverage determinations
- eCFR: 42 CFR 423.572, expedited coverage determinations
- Federal Register: Medicare appeals, amount in controversy thresholds for CY 2027 (September 16, 2026)
- CMS: Federal District Court Review
- CMS: Redetermination Request Form (CMS-20027)
- CMS: Reconsideration Request Form (CMS-20033)
- CMS: Appointment of Representative (CMS-1696)
- HHS: Request for Medicare Hearing by an ALJ (OMHA-100)
- NJ Division of Aging Services: PAAD
- NJ Division of Aging Services: SHIP
- Commence Health (formerly Livanta) BFCC-QIO
This guide is for general information. Program rules and income limits change, so confirm with the official source before you apply.



